PM Anwar clarifies federal appeal targets specific legal flaws in Sabah 40% revenue judgment, not the allocation itself, citing concerns since 1974.
KUALA LUMPUR: The Federal Government’s appeal focuses solely on legal aspects of the Sabah 40% revenue ruling, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim clarified today.
Anwar explained the appeal addresses specific flaws identified in the High Court of Sabah’s written judgment.
He stated the Attorney General’s Chambers advised that certain judgment portions exceeded their legal scope.
“The court’s reasoning that the review of the special allocation after 2021 was unlawful and irrational linked alleged major errors to the Federal Government dating back to 1974,” Anwar said.
“This ruling implies that all Federal Governments, state governments, and members of parliament involved since 1974 up to the current administration are deemed to have acted beyond their authority.”
He described the implication as a very serious matter requiring careful consideration.
Anwar urged all MPs to read the written judgment thoroughly to understand the legal complexities.
“I want to stress that I do not want this to become a political polemic over the 40% allocation itself, because that portion is not being appealed,” he emphasized.
The Prime Minister confirmed only statements deemed inconsistent or incorrect would be challenged through the appeal process.
He made these clarifications during Minister’s Question Time in the Dewan Rakyat today.
He was responding to a question from Datuk Mohd Shahar Abdullah (BN–Paya Besar) on the rationale behind the government’s decision not to challenge the overall ruling, but to appeal only on the grounds of legal irregularities and their implications.
The prime minister explained that discussions between the Federal and Sabah governments to review the grant rate were held during the tenure of former Prime Minister Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob, and that the increase was not done unilaterally.
He said the negotiations were legitimate and in line with Article 112D of the Federal Constitution.
“With Sabah’s agreement, the rate was raised in 2022 to RM125.6 million. When we continued with the special grant of RM600 million, it was accepted as an interim arrangement and has yet to be finalised by both Sabah and Sarawak through the MA63 Implementation Action Council — but this can be expedited,” he said.
Anwar also stressed that his explanation on the RM10 billion in federal revenue and RM17 billion in expenditure for Sabah was never intended to dispute the state’s 40 per cent entitlement.
He said the figures showed that Sabah had, in fact, benefited from greater overall federal spending in various forms of development expenditure.
Dismissing claims that the government had neglected Sabah’s rights, Anwar said such accusations were unfounded and inaccurate.
“For example, under MA63, the regulation of electricity supply must belong to Sabah, and we handed it over in January 2024. But even though it’s now under Sabah, we still provide RM1.2 billion for the state’s electricity needs.
“The same goes for RM765 million for the Southern Link transmission project, the MADANI Solar Hybrid programme launched in Sabah, RM1 billion for clean water supply, and the Pan Borneo Highway,” he said.
Anwar said these measures reflected the Federal Government’s commitment to continue negotiations on the 40 per cent revenue while ensuring that Sabah’s development needs remain a priority. – Bernama
